Tibbet's Catering Service & Menu

Got a custom dessert in mind? Not sure what your party needs? We can help!

All catering orders require at least 72-hour advance notice.


Oreo Truffles
Oreo treats dipped in chocolate. Available in original, mint, red velvet, birthday cake, golden, and chocolate. Seasonally we have salted caramel, carrot cake, strawberry, cookies and cream, smore, cinnabon, and peanut butter pie.

Small Trays - $25.00
Yields approx 20 Oreos
Large Trays - $50.00
Yields approx 50 Oreos

Our cookies are flavored cake cookies. These cookies are delicious and super moist so you don’t have to worry about them sitting out during your event. We have chocolate, chocolate chip, red velvet, cookies and cream, birthday cake, and brownie cookies available.

Small Trays - $25.00
Yields approx 20 cookies
Large Trays - $50.00
Yields approx 45 cookies

Ice Cream Sandwich Bar
Cookie and ice cream menu and toppings to be customized for your occasion.

Per Person - $5.00

Want an Ice Cream Sandwich Food Truck at your event? Contact us today to reserve your date!

Order For Your Party Now

Special Holiday Items

These are the items that are only available for a short amount of time.
(Our holiday season is October - December)

Lady Locks
Italian pastry cookies with a creamy filling dusted with powdered sugar and can be drizzled with a sauce at request.

Small Trays - $35.00 - Yields approx 50 cookies
Large Trays - $70.00 - Yields approx 120 cookies

Pie Bites
Delicious tiny pieces of pie crust coated in your choice of cinnamon sugar, chocolate drizzle, fruit drizzle, or powdered sugar.

Small Trays - $30.00 - Yields approx 175 pie bites
Large Trays - $60.00 - Yields approx 325 pie bites

Delectable pies with a crust of perfection. We have them available in pecan, pumpkin, cherry, and apple.

9” pies are $12.00 each
Gluten-free crust available for an extra fee.

Dessert Trays
Want a little bit of everything and not sure where to start. Leave the options up to us. Our dessert trays are more catered to the number of people you will have. You will get a mixture of everything we are currently running at that time.

Small Trays - $25.00 - Yields approx for 10 people
Large Trays - $50.00 - Yields approx for 30 people

Order For Your Party Now